Reply To: Song Book

Home › Forums › JoCo Tabs › Song Book › Reply To: Song Book

#37730
mtgordon
Participant

I do think we need to consider the intended audience, and I’m not sure I understand that yet. If I know the song already (having heard it a million times), and I just want to be able to accompany on guitar, I’m reasonably happy with just the lyrics and the abbreviations of the associated chords, and if the fingerings for the more obscure chords are available, so much the better, though the staff doesn’t get in the way much unless the song is overly long. I think half the reason that we use this approach so much is that it’s trivial to type, whether here or on YouTube. If I want to play the melody on an instrument, though, then having that melody on a staff is very useful, and having the chords above the staff doesn’t really cause much trouble. I’m not sure whether pianists would prefer to have the chords written out note for note on piano staves vs. the fake book approach, just having the melody on one staff and the chord abbreviations (and lyrics, of course). Sheet music for a complete piano arrangement (on piano staves) would seem a bit out of character, given that the songs in question weren’t written for piano accompaniment. Multi-instrument arrangements are another issue. In theory, the songs with multiple vocal parts (Camp Bachelor Alma Mater, My Monkey, When You Go, Stroller Town) could have each vocal part (and lyrics, when they differ between parts) written out separately, which might be useful, though it might be hard to pull these apart from the canonical recordings. The demos and live performances (in the absence of P&S, Kristen, or Molly) are for solo voice and guitar, in which case the fake book approach isn’t too much of a gross oversimplification, assuming the guitar part is reasonably simple, but the more serious studio recordings are all much more complicated, typically with multiple instruments, backing vocals, wailing guitar solos, etc. Even the live performances, which are necessarily sparse arrangements, might be best represented by a staff for the melody plus full-blown guitar tablature, i.e. a staff with six lines and numbers to specify explicitly what strings are being held down at which frets, plus notation for hammering on and the like. I understand that it’s impractical to enter such things in Vanilla or YouTube, and the “tabs” we’re used to seeing here are necessarily abbreviated for the available media, but for an actual book, we can do better. FWIW, I’ve been reading the docs for LilyPond, and I’m willing to help convert any hand-written sheet music or tablature to pretty typeset copy.

So, what’s the intended audience? Guitarist? Pianist? Gotta-own-everything fan? Pedantic JoCo scholars? Some combination of the above? The poll seems to be favoring a fairly conventional fake book, but with no more complex option in the poll, is it worth discussing more complex alternatives?