Reply To: Song Book
Based on Rob's comment above, how a little straw poll… I assume that guitarists appreciate tab (correct me if I'm wrong), but among the piano-playing folk here, what have your experiences been with standard piano/vocal published sheet music? Do you tend to read the written notes and play them exactly, or do you use that as a guide once you feel you have a grasp of the style?
I tend to find them disappointing, with the exception of some Broadway stuff and tinkly piano ballads. Many common styles don't lend themselves well to notation that is both accurate and easy to read, but maybe I'm just being lazy as an arranger. I just know that I struggle writing down the same notes I would happily play, and the struggle is doubly hard when the style isn't intended for piano. Having said that, maybe I should just grit my teeth and try a piano-vocal arrangement of a JoCo song.