Reply To: Song Book

Home › Forums › JoCo Tabs › Song Book › Reply To: Song Book

#37599
BorbaSpinotti
Participant

Sorry if I came over a bit boorish, hobbified – allow me to phrase things slightly differently: Picture me as the guy who uses MS Word on a PC, and we're all writing a book together. If collaboration requires everyone to use a different agreed-upon package on a different platform, someone like me is much less likely to be useful to the project, whereas I could still be useful if we agreed to collaborate using plain old ASCII text files or even HTML. The only point where it's worth committing to a particular package (and sorry for rehashing you, Bry) is where we've got the raw material in a form where someone with the right editorial flair can apply a unified presentation to it. Apologies for the dig at Lilypond, though; I should have been more careful to avoid any hint of judgmental phrasing!

Speaking as someone who has seen a good amount of decent and horrible fake books, a benchmark for me is Sher Music's Real Book series. Nice big notes, correct chords, no redundancy, and just enough detail to allow reasonable sight-readers to, umm, fake it. There needn't be a difference between piano and guitar presentation styles, since the aim would be to hit the salient points of a song in as few pages as possible. (Page turns bad.) What ups the page count, and the preparation time, is the kind of detail one finds in published sheet music arrangements, namely written-out piano parts and guitar chord frames.

My suggestion would be to focus on getting the canonical versions (recordings my personal preference!) notated in a simple fake book format first, and worry about fleshing out arrangements later and treat that as a separate medium.