Reply To: Song Book

Home › Forums › JoCo Tabs › Song Book › Reply To: Song Book

#37543
hobbified
Participant

If LilyPond doesn’t want to play along and include better support for the emerging standard of MusicXML, I’d say they are being a bit selfish, or more charitably, the developers haven’t jumped into that particular breach just yet.

Well, Lilypond is Turing-complete (it includes a Scheme interpreter), so it does stuff that MusicXML, being purely a document format, couldn’t even begin to represent. That seems like plenty enough reason not to have it as a native format. As pointed out, Lilypond does ship a tool that converts MusicXML to .ly. Conversion in the opposite direction, on the other hand, is impossible in the general case — it’s essentially the halting problem. It would be possible to write a converter that would work on the simplest Lilypond files without losing too much information, but I think the developers can be excused for not tackling a very hard problem that can never actually be solved.

What this means for workflow, if you don’t like entering Lilypond directly, is to do just as much as you can in a music-as-document notation editor like Sibelius or Rosegarden, save, export to Lilypond, and apply touchups from there.