Reply To: Song Book

Home › Forums › JoCo Tabs › Song Book › Reply To: Song Book

#37474
BorbaSpinotti
Participant

Yay for MusicXML! I can't say it has yet changed my life, but I have a lot of respect for Michael Good of Recordare, having observed some of his frustrations of getting MusicXML working with Sibelius and imagining that multiplied by the number of products he was shooting for.

The discussion is really moving on slightly diverging tracks here:
– what does it take to create a songbook? (simplest possible answer: enough individual contributions distributable as graphics files. Lacks presentational unity, but what the heck.)
– what is the best unified format to present such a songbook in, if it came to that?

My knowledge of notation programs is probably typical: I use a particular one (Sibelius) because I have always used it (or insert own flamewar-inducing opinion here), and I have no need, motivation or resources to learn another one. MusicXML makes it possible to have *some* kind of document exchange with non-Sibelius users, and that is pretty good going compared to not sharing at all. If LilyPond doesn't want to play along and include better support for the emerging standard of MusicXML, I'd say they are being a bit selfish, or more charitably, the developers haven't jumped into that particular breach just yet. It does seem to be acceptable practice nowadays to keep one's own native file format while including support for XML-based ones in both directions.

As a potential contributor – and I emphasise the "potential" because I don't seem to have the time to do much nowadays – I could happily contribute exported MusicXML files based on Sibelius documents. In my little world, the Sibelius document would be the canonical one, and it would be an editorial problem getting that to appear correctly/appropriately in another environment. Self-centred, but workable, given the paucity of options.

Disclaimer: I don't honestly know what the current version of MusicXML supports – it's been a few years since I was really following along. But even assuming that basic notes and lyrics are encoded well, I don't know what the situation is with chord symbols and the like.