Reply To: Song Book

Home › Forums › JoCo Tabs › Song Book › Reply To: Song Book

#37440
Bry
Participant

I’ve caught wiki-fever, and I’d love to see this, too, as another collaborative project. And here’s my ill-informed input:

For online collaborative music-transcription projects, there’s Musipedia, the online and searchable database of melodies (actually really useful if you have something whose name you can’t seem to remember stuck in your head). I don’t know if they’ve improved their music-entry system since several months ago (when I last edited something) — I never registered, and nowadays they require registration to edit. But the notation-display uses GNU LilyPond.

At which point, I’ve spent something like an hour researching this, which isn’t enough to make me more than conversant on these subjects, but as far as open file formats go, LilyPond and MusicXML appear to be the two standards. Each has its advantages and disadvantages, which I’ll attempt to list in no particular order:
* MusicXML is just a format (which can be read, etc., by different programs); LilyPond is a notation creator — it takes input data in its specific (text) format and converts it into notation, formatted the way that’s specified in the data.
* Thus, you can read MusicXML using a whole bunch of different programs – Finale and Sibelius both support it, according to its software list. This is not true of LilyPond — there are a couple of GUIs available, but it hasn’t been widely picked up by non-LilyPond-specific programs.
* But LilyPond gives you control over appearances, where MusicXML doesn’t — e.g. in MusicXML you can say “slur A, C, B”, but you can’t tell it to “slur A, C, B, but make the C and B closer together and curve the slur upwards”. (This is part of why LilyPond isn’t likely to be picked up by non-LilyPond-specific programs… it wants way too much control over these things.)
* There’s already a MediaWiki “interface”, WikiTeX, that “supports editing LilyPond notation directly in wiki articles” (quoted from Wikipedia on LilyPond). So if we go that route, we could even coerce Lex into installing WikiTeX on JoCopedia and share all the work there, which would be pretty cool because we’d have it all available from the songs pages themselves. That’s a really exciting prospect. I can’t seem to find a quality webapp that does MusicXML — as far as I can tell, you can’t work with it directly online.
* On the other hand, if we do it in MusicXML, those of us using the most popular scorewriters don’t have to relearn anything. (And the above-linked MusicXML software list links to converters from Noteworthy Composer format to MusicXML and vice versa.)
* Along the same lines, MusicXML can be converted to LilyPond but not vice versa. The LilyPond developers aren’t interested in making it more convertible (they feel their product is superior, and they don’t want to encourage moving away from it, and also they’re focusing on making their product better rather than writing converters). So if we start in LilyPond, we’re stuck for the duration.

Thoughts?