I'm checking my last.fm…
My Top 7 songs on there are Coulton songs, in this order:
The Future Soon (38)
Re: Your Brains (37)
First of May (35)
Ikea (35)
You Ruined Everything (35)
I Feel Fantastic (33)
Code Monkey (32)
It would probably add up to Code Monkey or You Ruined Everything being first though… I have live versions of both of those songs that have high play counts, to go along with the Thing A Week versions.