Reply To: The rest of the story: what happens after the lyrics end in Creepy Doll?
Spiff, you have a Creepy Doll video? I'll definitely have to check it out. 
I agree with what you "officially" said about that line in Creepy Doll. It seems to fit with the rest of the song.
By the way, one other thing I was trying to determine: in the second verse, the victim goes "antiquing" and buys an old wooden box with a key that mysteriously sports his or her own name. The next line says:
"And you know what you will find inside the moment that you see
That someone carved your name into the tarnished silver key"
…So, does that imply that the victim opens the box and finds – gasp – the creepy doll that was quite possibly seen in the attic previously?