If one criterion is how long the lyric insists on circling through your head, then the one I currently can't get out of mine is from "Brookline":
It's one if by land and two if by sea
Three if by guile and duplicity
A nice slide-the-knife-in phrase.
Sign Up for the Jonathan Coulton Mailing List!
We'll send you four free tracks to start,
we'll never give your address to others,
and we'll make sure you know about the latest
news and upcoming concerts.