Reply To: Electric vs. Acoustic
Home › Forums › JoCo Gigs › Electric vs. Acoustic › Reply To: Electric vs. Acoustic
Speaking as someone who has played both acoustic and electric guitar with bands — one aspect to it is that acoustic tends to afford you more subtlety and control. You can control the volume very intuitively with your fingers and with palm muting and with your pick technique. Now, you can do this somewhat on electric if you play more clean jazz-style, but most of the electric sounds that JoCo uses and we'd expect to hear on these songs are higher-gain and highly compressed, where even light pick attack produces a similar output volume. So you have to rely a lot on the sound man to keep you in balance. I think most tones you get out of an electric guitar can tend to be a bit more fatiguing to listen to for a whole set.
Switching between acoustic and electric — and dialing in different lead or rhythm sounds for different songs — with my church band was a bit of a bear, especially trying to keep levels inline with the other musicians; I can understand why a musician wouldn't want to manage all that gear if he/she didn't absolutely have to.
I've got a couple of "hybrid" guitars — a Godin nylon-string electric, which will also drive guitar synth, which sounds very cool, and a Parker Fly, with a piezo output which also sounds very cool, quite acoustic-like. I like both of these but they are not _really_ acoustic and I can understand why JoCo is attached to the woody tone of a real Martin acoustic.