Reply To: Lyrics and gender

Home › Forums › JoCo Music › Lyrics and gender › Reply To: Lyrics and gender

#51127
Bry
Participant

three08: I think you and I are on the same page. I read “Till the Money Comes” the same way I read “Soft Rocked By Me” — I don’t think either of the narrators is actually going to get what he wants. The only difference, to me, is that I can imagine that Soft Rocked Guy can be slick enough to hide his true colors until it’s too late.

In the JoCoeuvre, I can draw a neat little ‘objectification of women’ continuum down from “Millionaire Girlfriend” (which I’ve mentioned is one of my favorites) through “Till the Money Comes” to “Soft Rocked By Me”, from more earnest to less so — that’s my perception, at least, and it relates directly to how much I like the narrators. (I acknowledge the less charitable reading of “Millionaire Girlfriend,” especially considering that JoCo said it was an attempt at creating a “loathsome” narrator [a word I stole for my post above], but it’s such an over-the-top fantasy that I find it sweet.) Also interesting to note that apparently I’m more okay with using someone for money than for love… although yet again my reading is that the MGF* and TTMC narrators are pretty much upfront about it.

*adopting this abbreviation for mtgordon’s sake

To continue my trend of replying to posts in the “Always the Moon lyrics” thread in this thread, let me respond to Luke M’s post, or at least the part that doesn’t overlap with what I’ve already said above [sorry, I tend to assume that everyone else reads everything too — I should’ve left a comment in that thread to redirect traffic].

I don’t think the male narrators of these songs are necessarily supposed to be sympathetic, or that their problems with women are supposed to accurately reflect what’s going on with the women… “Problematic gender relations” certainly, but if anything the trend I see is not that JoCo is bashing women, but that so many of his male characters are dateless wonders who are being mocked by the lyrics.

Yes, that’s clear enough, and I might add “Skullcrusher Mountain” to your heaps of examples. (I’ve written above that there are plenty of unsavory men to go along with the unsavory women.) The question, though, is: Even if we recognize that what we’re supposed to do is laugh at / disagree with the narrators, even knowing that JoCo intends them to be unreliable, can we still find them worrisome? If (and this is an extreme example that wouldn’t happen in a JoCo song, obviously) a character was dropping slurs and obscenities all over the place, would the fact that the character was meant as satire be enough to excuse everything? (And to be clear, I don’t mean that satire should be censored or stifled or anything, just, y’know, not liked.)

I think JoCo stays on the fair side of the line for me, for the most part, and part of that is that he’s funny (which excuses a lot, for me). Once again, I’d be interested in seeing him try a different angle on this, though.

That said, chauvinistic troglodyte that I am, I didn’t blink at the second verse of “Always the Moon,” but three08’s cogent analysis has left me, if not totally convinced, at least uneasy about its message. For one thing, it doesn’t seem to be overtly satirical, unless JoCo’s making a Jutzesque play on the Christian creation myth being as mythical as a giant oyster birthing the world. And the Eve / forbidden fruit thing does have the historical baggage three08 mentions, about being used to excuse all sorts of misogyny, particularly taken in light of the line, “we all know who’s to blame.”