Reply To: JoCopedia
Home › Forums › JoCo Projects › JoCopedia › Reply To: JoCopedia
Didn’t, of course, get around to writing Editing Guidelines. I’ll try and draft up a few brief points — I’d appreciate y’all’s input (and revisions) once I do. Answering other points in no particular order:
Is there a reason why the shop vac video page has the sub-menu (lyrics, tabs, videos, other) at the base of the page, while the others have it at the top (which I think is the correct place)?
Good catch, Kerrin — I’ve moved the nav-menu for consistency. (Although as Mason points out, the song main pages still have it at the bottom of the page. Right or wrong, I dunno.)
[Also, Kerrin, I apologized because I didn’t want to make it seem as though I was mocking you or anything by quoting you earlier — it was entirely in appreciation of what you wrote.]
Re: hard to navigate back: Wikipedia solves the main summary page / secondary pages (not literally “subpages,” though) problem with their templating — take a look, for a random example, at the bar at the bottom of Wikipedia: Norse mythology. What would you guys think of retooling the song-nav-menu template to imitate something like that?
ETA: Here’s their navbox template, on which the other specific navigation templates (e.g. the Norse mythology one) tend to be based.
Mark: The two DSJDs have different pages, so that shouldn’t be a problem, I think. Unless you had something else in mind?
Lex, Mason, et al.: I really like album pages (rather than albums as categories), and I’d strongly advocate for their use — mostly because they give us more control over appearance (instead of having big “0” and “1” headings), and they are few enough that it isn’t unreasonable to do them mostly by hand. But I have no objection to leaving the albums as categories, whether temporarily or permanently, if that’s what others have in mind.
Question: “When I’m 25 or Sixty-Four” was left off of the TAW1 CD, so what happens to it, album-wise? It doesn’t really have a “track number” per se, but it was released between “Town Crotch” and “Podsafe Christmas Song”. (This is one of the reasons I’d like an album page, but that’s neither here nor there.)